Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Samuel and Jacob revisit The Girl Who Waited, one of the Eleventh Doctor era’s most emotionally brutal character pieces. They break down Amy’s decades of isolation, Rory’s impossible choice, the Doctor’s darker and more calculating side, and why the episode’s emotional payoff works so well—even when the setup starts falling apart under closer inspection.

Highlights:

• Why the episode’s entire premise could have been avoided with better communication.
• Older Amy’s transformation and Karen Gillan’s powerful performance.
• Rory reaching full “main character energy” as he fights to save both versions of Amy.
• The hosts debate just how much the Doctor knew—and whether he deliberately manipulated Amy and Rory.
• The devastating final choice between younger and older Amy.
• How Doctor Who turns a relatively low-budget setting into a memorable sci-fi environment.
• Plus: the birth of a new podcast running gag

To find previous episodes go to: tscn.tv/gtw

To subscribe to this podcast put this link in your favorite podcatcher:

http://feeds.feedburner.com/GoingThroughWho

Want to support our content? Go to tscn.tv/support to find out how!

Send feedback to: goingthroughwho@gmail.com or comment in the post below!

Artwork by Baniee

Theme music by ThePantychrist

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Samuel and Jacob take a trip into the dollhouse for Night Terrors, as the Eleventh Doctor answers a frightened child’s call for help. They discuss the episode’s creepy concepts, the effectiveness of the peg dolls, and how George’s fears shape the story. Along the way, Samuel brings a counseling perspective to the episode’s portrayal of childhood anxiety, while both hosts examine why a strong premise, great performances, and an emotional ending don’t quite overcome some frustrating pacing and storytelling choices.

Highlights

• Behind-the-scenes facts and trivia from the Matrix
• The creepy concept and design of the peg dolls
• George’s fears through a counseling and child-development lens
• Why language, communication, and reframing matter
• The Doctor’s relationship with George and his father
• Amy and Rory’s trip through the mysterious dollhouse
• Why the episode’s pacing weakens an otherwise excellent concept
• The emotional reveal behind George’s greatest fear
• Thoughts on the underexplored mystery of the Tenza
• Matt Smith and the cast delivering standout performances

To find previous episodes go to: tscn.tv/gtw

To subscribe to this podcast put this link in your favorite podcatcher:

http://feeds.feedburner.com/GoingThroughWho

Want to support our content? Go to tscn.tv/support to find out how!

Send feedback to: goingthroughwho@gmail.com or comment in the post below!

Artwork by Baniee

Theme music by ThePantychrist

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Samuel and Jacob return to Doctor Who Series 6 with Let’s Kill Hitler, an episode whose provocative title quickly gives way to a much bigger story about River Song, Amy, Rory, and the Doctor. They discuss the episode’s risky use of Hitler, the introduction of the Teselecta, Rory’s increasingly heroic streak, and the major revelations surrounding Melody Pond’s transformation into River Song.

Episode Highlights

• Debate over whether using Hitler as a comedic plot device was worth the narrative gamble.
• The reveal that Amy and Rory’s childhood friend Mels is actually Melody Pond.
• Alex Kingston stealing the show as a newly regenerated River Song.
• The Teselecta, its hilariously polite antibodies, and some questionable time-travel justice.
• Rory continuing his evolution into an action hero—including punching Nazis.
• How the episode fills in major pieces of River Song’s complicated timeline.
• The Doctor and River’s clever battle of wits as she attempts to kill him.
• Amy and Rory confronting the bittersweet reality that they unknowingly helped raise their own daughter.
• The sonic cane, River learning to fly the TARDIS, and plenty of classic Steven Moffat timey-wimey storytelling.

To find previous episodes go to: tscn.tv/gtw

To subscribe to this podcast put this link in your favorite podcatcher:

http://feeds.feedburner.com/GoingThroughWho

Want to support our content? Go to tscn.tv/support to find out how!

Send feedback to: goingthroughwho@gmail.com or comment in the post below!

Artwork by Baniee

Theme music by ThePantychrist

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Samuel and Jacob dive into A Good Man Goes to War, the explosive midseason finale of Doctor Who Series 6. They discuss Rory’s transformation into the Last Centurion, the Doctor assembling an army and confronting the frightening reputation he has built across the universe, the introduction of Vastra, Jenny, and Strax, and the long-awaited revelation of River Song’s true identity. Along the way, they explore what the episode says about morality, war, faith, military identity, and whether the Doctor is really the “good man” of the title

Episode Highlights

• Rory steps fully into his role as the Last Centurion while searching for Amy.
• The Doctor calls in old debts and assembles an unlikely army for the battle at Demon’s Run.
• Samuel and Jacob debate whether the “good man” going to war is actually Rory rather than the Doctor.
• The episode forces the Doctor to confront how terrifying his reputation has become throughout the universe.
• Vastra, Jenny, and Strax make their memorable introductions.
• The religious military forces at Demon’s Run spark a larger conversation about faith, organized religion, war, and military identity.
• How Steven Moffat uses time travel to make the River Song reveal possible in a uniquely Doctor Who way.

To find previous episodes go to: tscn.tv/gtw

To subscribe to this podcast put this link in your favorite podcatcher:

http://feeds.feedburner.com/GoingThroughWho

Want to support our content? Go to tscn.tv/support to find out how!

Send feedback to: goingthroughwho@gmail.com or comment in the post below!

Artwork by Baniee

Theme music by ThePantychrist